MA course 2018-2019

Sinographics

 

Chinese writing & writing Chinese

 

Jeroen Wiedenhof

Index

 

General information

e-Prospectus catalog number: 5174KCH45

For details see

Time and venue

Time: 11:15am - 1:00pm

Venue: Vrieshof 1, room 006

Sessions

Block 3

Week 1 (4 Feb 19)

Intro / Speaking and writing in China

Writing is – in most definitions – connected with language. But if language travels through sound waves and writing is a visual medium, then how do these two domains interact?

Writing systems displays intricate and diverse ways of mapping the sounds and meanings of language to a visual format.

Once written down, some elements from speech are preserved and some are lost. And vice versa: the visual signal may transmit components from the spoken original, but also features which are absent in spoken form.

In this first session, we will explore how language comes to us through the Chinese script – and how fast such modes can change.

Texts


Study suggestions

Time management: do not underestimate assignment #5 below. It may involve more reference checking than would seem at first glance.

Assignments

Please make sure you prepare your answers to all questions & assignments in writing.

1.  Read the assigned chapter from Jerry Norman's Chinese.

In preparing this text, please check that you are familiar with

  • technical terms in English and in Mandarin (including the corresponding Chinese characters);

  • names and dates for dynasties, historical periods and historical figures;

  • geographical designations.

Note down any difficulties you may have in reading the text, and bring your notes to class.

2.  On p. 58, the origins of Chinese characters are outlined.

a.  In English, do you know a term for the study of writing systems? And in Mandarin?

b.  Can you name (at least) three families of scripts, i.e. writing systems of the world which (as far as we know) developed independently?

c.  Is the oracle bone script the undisputed precursor of the modern Chinese character script?

d.  Can you name (at least) seven different Sinitic languages?

Please give the English and in Mandarin names for each of these, as well as the Chinese characters (简体 & 繁體) for each name.

e.  What is the oldest Sinitic phase which has been reconstructed in phonological detail? Please give (approximate) dates.

f.  Is the language encoded by the oracle bone script the undisputed precursor of the modern Sinitic languages?

3.  The ideographic notion, i.e. the notion "that Chinese characters in some platonic fashion directly represent ideas rather than specific Chinese words" may be "patently absurd" (pp. 60-61), but it is immensely popular nonetheless.

Find a reference (in print or online) which clearly demonstrates, or is clearly based on, the ideographic notion.

a.  From this source, note down one specific statement or claim demonstrating this notion.

b.  Formulate a counter-argument against this specific statement or claim, basing yourself (at least in part) on the information in section 3.1.

4.  Pages 67-69 introduce the 說文解字.

In one or two sentences, summarize the significance of this work

  • for the study of the Chinese script; and

  • for Chinese lexicography.

5.  On p. 76, please study Table 3.6 carefully, including the notes on p. 77.

a.  Can you read all characters listed in the Table?

For your reference: see e.g.

b.  Can you give more recent examples of individual characters created in order to "adapt[...] the traditional script to the modern language" (p. 75)?

6.  In note 8 of p. 81, please define the term homophonous in your own words.

7.  In note 10 of p. 82, it is noted that "the alternation of words beginning with sh and r in a single phonetic series is unusual".

Find another example of this unusual type of alternation in the traditional character script.

8.  In the same note 10, consider the example of ràng 'to allow' again.

Note that "ràng" is italicized, but " 'to allow' " is placed within single quotation marks.

a.  In your own words, formulate the difference between these typographical conventions.

Which linguistic units do they represent?

b.  Can you list other typographical conventions, representing other linguistic units?

For each unit, give English and Mandarin names, as well as the Chinese characters (简体 & 繁體).

c.  Is there also a typographical convention which represents items as orthographic units, i.e. as the written forms of a script?


Week 2 (11 Feb 19)

Language and script (1):

The structure of Chinese characters

The Chinese script has been studied for millennia, both in and outside China, giving rise to a bewildering set of principles, approaches and perspectives.

This week, we are covering some groundwork in terms of data, units of analysis, methods and terminology.

We will also check on the logistics of this course: finding your way around the relevant catalogues, the course reserves shelves and the library collections.

Texts

Assignments

Please make sure you prepare your answers to all questions & assignments in writing.

9.  Group efforts:

(a)  Next week (in session 3), we will be reading a text in Chinese.

For now, if you cannot read modern written Chinese:

  • Prepare to buddy up!
  • Please make sure to contact classmates now, and to set a date & time to prepare next week's text together.
  • If needed, make use of the Blackboard "Course Tools" option to send group emails.

(b)  Meanwhile, here is some of the feedback I received since Session 1:

  • Thanks to Mara for pointing out that Norman's linguistics classic Chinese is also available as an e-book [info added 8 Feb 19]
  • Thanks to Valéri for pointing out access problems with the 國際電腦漢字及異體字知識庫 database [options added 8 Feb 19]

On Chao (1968):

10.  Bibliography

On the basis of the University Library catalogues, inventorize all editions of Y.R. Chao's Grammar of spoken Chinese. For each title,

(a)  Note place & year of publication, name of the publisher and other relevant details;

(b)  Check which transcription for Mandarin has been used;

(c)  Check if the work is available on the Asian Library's open shelves;

(d)  If (c) = yes, find one example of an empty square representing a spoken expression without a character and note down the page number.

On Norman (1988):

11.  Review

of last week's text & assignments:

On Dougherty e.a. (1963):

12.  Read the text, note down any difficulties you may have in reading the text, and bring your notes to class.

13.  In the Preface, check which personal names ring familiar.

14.  On p. ix/L,

a.  What is meant by "the standard pronunciation(s)"?

b.  What is the difference between transcription, "transliterations systems" and "romanization"?

15.  On p. x/R, in Figure 2, check and see if you are missing any details.

16.  On p. xi/L, character #5536 is shown twice in Figure 3.

Now compare character #1788.1 in Figure 2. What is the reason that this character is not shown twice?

17.  Make sure you are familiar with the calligraphic terminology on pp. xi/R-xii/L.

In one sentence, describe the relevance of these terms are in this context; also compare assigment #19 below.

18.  Check the Rules on pp. xix-xxi and the Concordance on pp. xxii-xxix. And/or look up any online resource on the Gwoyeu Romatzyh transcription.

On the basis of this information, see if you can read (pronounce & translate) the Chinese book titles listed on p. xxx.

Be prepared to cite these titles by reading them out aloud in class.

19.  On the basis of your reading of this Introduction, can you formulate a technical definition for the term Chinese character as implied here?


Week 3 (18 Feb 19)

Corresponding with Heaven: The early scribes

At the dawn of history, humans were fully modern in the anatomical and in the neurological sense. Their brains, and their languages, were as complex and as diverse as they are today. There were just fewer speakers.

Even at this early stage, the world must have been teeming with linguists. We know nothing about their theories, but their legacy remains with us today, for they created the first writing systems.

The art of writing was invented more than once, and the puzzle how to represent sound and meaning in graphs has been solved in very different ways. The Chinese case offers us a rare insight in the tenacity of some cultural artefacts.

This week, we will:

  • study the material culture which produced a script whose characteristics have survived into the digital age;

  • consider the challenges of interdisciplinary studies; and

  • learn how to introduce a text dating back more than three millennia to a modern audience.

Interactive scans: Hi Res / Low Res
Source: Cambridge UL Oracle Bone CUL.52
Interactive scan by Sketchfab (2015)

Texts



Background

NASA Goddard Space Flight Center, "Lunar eclipse essentials"

Development notes: For future runs of this course

Source to be considered

On the sexagesimal cycle:

Michel Ferlus, The sexagesimal cycle, from China to Southeast Asia , from China to Southeast Asia. 23rd Annual Conference of the Southeast Asian Linguistics Society, May 2013, Bangkok, Thailand.

Reading notes

20.  In case you need help with the Wade-Giles spelling:

– for systematic guidelines & conversion, see Appendix D in A grammar of Mandarin; or

– for ad-hoc conversion, see e.g. the Chinese Text Project's transcription-conversion tool.

21.  In case you need help with the sexagesimal cycle:

– for systematic guidelines & conversion, see Tables 9.3 & 9.4 in A grammar of Mandarin; or

– for ad-hoc conversion, see e.g. Wikipedia's Stem, Branch and Stem-Branch tables.

22.  "Wu Ting's reign" (Keightley 1985: 1):

Wikipedia has a list of Shang Kings.


Assignments

23.  Individual items

Cheyann: Your backlog assignments for week 1(written answers to Assignments 1 through 8) are due this Friday, 15 Feb 19, at 1:00pm.

The assignments for this week's session are below.

A friendly reminder: make sure to prepare all your answers in writing, in English!

– Keightley (1985):

24.  Read the assigned texts from David Keightley's Sources.

In preparing this text, please check that you are familiar with

  • technical terms in English and in Mandarin, including the corresponding Chinese characters,
  • – e.g. "hsin-wei, eighth day of the week";
  • names and dates for dynasties, historical periods and historical figures

    – e.g. "Wu Ting";

  • geographical designations

    – e.g. "the powerful Ho".

For hints and suggestions, please consult the Reading notes.

Note down any difficulties you may have in reading the text, and bring your notes to class.

25.  In the interactive scan and in the illustration above, please identify the "series of hollows" (Keightley 1985: 18) and "the characteristic pu 卜-shaped crack" (ibid.).

26.  On p. 50, it is explained that "[a]s a rule, the inscriptions appear to have been carved above, or to the side of, the pu cracks and on the side of the crack which lacked the transverse branch".

Can you confirm this general rule for our "月㞢食" text?


– Lǐ (1989):

27.  On the basis of 李圃 Lí Pǔ's helpful notes, read and prepare an English translation of the oracle bone text "月㞢食".

Please note down any difficulties encountered in Lǐ's commentary.

28.  Oracular text, line 4, character 2:

In your own words, define the relationship between the character 㞢 and the character 有.

You should minimally formulate what you know on the basis of Pǔ's comments, combined with your own experience.

In this connection, also compare the comments on character adaptations from our first session.

For more background, you may consult Djamouri (1992).

FYI

29.  In Session 2, Lorenzo's question prompted a brief explanation how textual information used to be stored digitally on paper tape.

Here are some suggestions for further reading & viewing:

[VIDEO] Binary counter (百聞不如一見;-)

– the Baudot-Murray code

– the ASCII code

– the 国标 Guóbiāo code

[VIDEO] Five-hole paper tape: writing and reading digital data

 

 

 

 


Week 4 (25 Feb 19)

Doing right by a script: The tools of lexicography

In Session 3, we saw how the invention of writing was embedded in technological and economic change.

Today, we will explore early advances in Chinese lexicography against the backdrop of philosophical and political developments In Qín 秦 and Hàn 漢 times.

This session will consist of two parts:

    • This weeks' centerpiece:

      An unconventional look at the establishment of writing conventions

    • Looking ahead:

      Exploring possibilities for you term paper

Texts

From Wikipedia: The free encyclopedia

Source: Archive.org


許慎 Xǔ Shèn, 說文解字 Shuō wén jiě zì [Discussion of simple characters and analysis of complex characters]

Edition: 说文解字: 附检字 Shuō wén jiě zì: Fù jiǎn zì [Discussion of simple characters and analysis of complex characters: With a character index].

北京 Peking: 中華書局 Zhōnghuá shūjú, 1963.

East Asian Library number: SINOL. 5093

Available in the Leiden Asian Library: see the dedicated Course Shelf, number ALCRS052, for this course.


Assignments

Hand-in Assignment #1

Imagine that:

  • the five fragments pieced together to form last week's oracle bone were shown in a museum exhibition, and
  • you were asked to write the accompanying object label, intended for an English-speaking museum audience.

On the basis of your work for last week's assignments, prepare a text which could serve as that object label. This text should minimally include:

  • information about the age and the provenance of the object;
  • short remarks about the type of text, and the language of the inscription;
  • a full translation of the "月㞢食" text.

Hand in your work, printed on paper, at the beginning of class on 25 February, or in my pigeonhole beforehand.

Please note the format requirements.

Small is beautiful: maximally one page (A4).


30.  Individual items

Valéri: Your backlog assignments for week 3 (written answers to Assignments 24 through 26 & 28) are due this Friday, 22 Feb 19, at 1:00pm.

– This week's centerpiece:

31.  Read the first two texts:

    • Galambos' Chapter Two, "The Qin and Han creation of the standard" and
    • the Wikipedia article "Shuowen Jiezi".

Note down any difficulties you may encounter in these two texts, and bring your notes to class.

We will discuss your questions and remarks on a page-by-page basis.

32.  The third title is a modern reprint of the 說文解字 Shuō wén jiě zì.

(a) Have a good look at this book, which is currently available from the course reserve shelves in the Leiden Asian Library.

(b) Check that you understand how the work is organised.

(c) Find the characters , , and in this dictionary.

For each of these four characters, write down

  • the page number for the entry in this modern edition
  • the Shuō wén jiě zì radical
  • the dictionary's definition of the characters, and
  • an English translation of this definition

– Looking ahead:

33.  Prepare some notes and ideas for your term paper.

Make a list of possible observations and, for each observation, one or more research questions.

Please bring your notes to class for discussion.

You can read more on the relevance (and art) of observation here.

 

...and the encore

34.  What is this?

–Thanks to Koos Kuiper for contributing this example

 

 

 

35.  Please comment!

–Thanks to Fresco Sam-Sin for contributing this example

 

 

 

 


Week 5 (4 Mar 19)

"By far the largest corpus of early Chinese manuscripts available to us today is the huge cache found by Sir Aurel Stein and others at Dunhuang in far western China in the early years of the twentieth century."

Peter Kornicki, "Bluffing your way in Chinese" (2008: 2)

Diamonds from Sand City: Dūnhuáng's linguistic treasures

Since times immemorial, the desert trails connecting India with China were busily travelled by merchants and monks, artists and adventurers.

This week, we zoom in on the oasis town of Dūnhuáng 敦煌, a.k.a. 沙州 Shāzhōu 'Sand City', whose Mògāo 莫高 caves have been a Unesco World Heritage Site since 1987.

One of the first scholars who realized that this site harbored a priceless linguistic time capsule was the Hungarian-born Briton Stein Márk Aurél, later Sir Marc Aurel Stein (1862-1943).

Initially attracted to Dūnhuáng by its Buddhist art, Stein chanced upon a cave full of manuscripts and prints in 1907. Today, the study of Dūnhuáng documents remains a fascinating multi-disciplinary field.

Texts

 

Susan Whitfield, "Stein's Silk Road legacy revisited".

In: Asian affairs, volume 40, no. 2, 2009, pp. 224-242.

Available as an e-publication from the Leiden University Library.

 

  • Volume II, Texts and

  • Volume IV, Plates

    Aurel Stein, K.C.I.E., Serindia: Detailed report of explorations in Central Asia and westernmost China

    Oxford: Clarendon, 1921.

    Availability

    (1) Leiden University Library's Special Collections

    Due to their age, these two volumes are not accessible as "Course Reserve" items.

    You need to got to the Special Collections Reading Room to consult these works. This reading room is on the same floor as the Asian Library, but two corridors across.

    Special Collections are making these volumes available for students of this Sinographics course. Just show your library card at the desk and remind library staff that both volumes are reserved under my name.

    (2) Digital edition

    Toyo Bunko Rare Books

    Click on the large photo's on the left hand side to access each volume


Reading notes

Whitfield (2009):

36.  The map shown on p. 225 is available online as a scalable color map from the British Library.


Background

Susan Whitfield, Aurel Stein on the Silk Road

London: British Museum Press, 2004.

Published at the occasion of the British Library exhibition "The silk road: Trade, travel, war and faith".

Includes a glossary.

Available in the Leiden Asian Library: see the dedicated Course Shelf, number ALCRS052, for this course.

International Dunhuang Project, "Conserving the Diamond Sutra".

Uploaded on Youtube on 27 May 2009.

Fascinating footage on the multi-disciplinary challenges of preserving the world's oldest dated printed text.

More video's from the IDP are available at their Youtube channel

 

Peter Kornicki, "Bluffing your way in Chinese".

Sandars Lectures in Bibliography,

Cambridge University Library, 11 March 2008.


Assignments

Left over from last week:

– "Doing right by a script", Assignments 32(c) through 35

  • #32(c) – 說文解字: We will have another look at your translations of these four entries.

With the aid of last week's notes, make sure that these four these items have no more secrets.

We will restrict ourselves to the main text, leaving 反切 fǎnqiè additions and other commentaries for later.

  • #33 – Term paper preparations

    By way of orientation, have a look at this introduction: Writing on language

37.  Backlog items

Jur: Your backlog assignments for week 4 (written answers to Assignments 31, 32 and 33) are due this Friday, 1 Mar 19, at 1:00pm.

38.  Individual items

Chengcheng: Stein's Volume II: Text notices that the sutra scroll was "in excellent preservation and complete".

Elaborate conservation was undertaken in the years 2003-2010, as shown in a British Library video on the Conservation of the Diamond Sutra.

Now, compare Stein's original picture with the photo taken at the British Museum in the mid-1970s.

Can you point out what type(s) of restoration or conservation work had been performed by that time?

Cheyann: Aurel Stein was not only a trained philologist, but also a skilled archeologist, "recognizing the importance of careful excavation, of stratigraphy and of recording each find's location" (Whitfield 2004: 18).

In two or three sentences, describe the technique of stratigraphy. When did this technique originate?

Chiara: There is a short Chinese text preceding the translation of the Diamond Sutra itself.

What does the first line say?

Jasper: Among the Dunhuang manuscripts, there are detailed drawings of hands held in many different positions.

(a) Find one of these drawings in Stein's Volume IV: Plates.

(b) Do they depict hand positions or hand gestures? What was the purpose of such drawings?

Jur: What is the Chinese term for 'archeology'? And what does it literally mean – morpheme by morpheme?

39.  Read Whitfield (2009) and bring your reading notes to class.

We will discuss your questions and remarks on a page-by-page basis.

40.  Make a list of all language names mentioned in this text, restricting yourself to languages spoken natively in the areas explored by Stein.

For each of these languages, look up their genetic affiliation (language family, subgroup, branch etc).

For some assistance, try the Linguistic Toolbox at the bottom of this page.

41.  In two or three sentences, summarize what Fāng considers to be the major challenge(s) for the digitization of Dunhuang manuscripts today.

42.  First, have a good look at Volumes II and V of Aurel Stein's original work of 1921.

In Volume IV: Plates, check that you understand the page numbering system.

On page C of Volume IV: Plates, find the photo of the "printed roll" at the lower half of the page;

on the same page, find Stein's inventory number for this item;

and in Volume II: Text, under the same inventory number, find Stein's detailed description of the item.

Now, establish whether Stein himself realized the historical significance of this particular scroll.

43.  The International Dunhuang Project (IDP) has uploaded a high-resolution image of the same scroll, which contains the full Chinese text of the Diamond Sutra.

This webpage includes a digital facsimile edition of the scroll, along with a full English translation of the sutra.

 

On the IDP page, if you click on "NEXT IMAGE" once,

you will have reached the last line of the printed text, indicating its date of publication. (to see more details, click "LARGE IMAGE")

This line of text is lacking in the IDP translation, but you will find an English translation in the short but useful introduction to the Diamond Sutra by the Silkroad Foundation.

(a) Correct the Silkroad Foundation's English translation of the Chinese date.

(b) Find the name of the emperor ruling the Táng 唐 at the time of publication of this scroll.

(c) Use the Chinese-Western calendar converter provided by the Academia Sinica, Taiwan, to check if the Julian date give by the Silkroad Foundation is correct.

(d) Check if you can tell on what day of the Julian week this Chinese edition of the Diamond Sutra was published.


Week 6 (12 Mar 19)

Museum excursion heads-up

In Block 4, we will be planning a visit to the depots of the Leiden's ethnography museum: the Museum Volkenkunde.

For this purpose, we need to inventorize which students from or group are in possession of a national Museumkaart.

Please mail me, or tell me in class whether you own one: I am drawing up a list.



Catching up and looking ahead: Linguistic approaches to sinographics

Over this first semester's block, we have been tackling an abundance of subjects from many different angles. This calls for a moment of reflection; remember that reflection is one of the most powerful instruments in the toolbox of science.

This week, therefore, we will cover some backlog from Week 1 to Week 5, as well as discuss any outstanding issues from these sessions which you may wish to raise.

We will also be look ahead to the tasks before us, first and foremost about the subjects of your term papers.

Week 6 (12 Mar 19)

Texts

See <writing_on_language.htm>

Annie Murphy Paul, "How to increase your powers of observation".

Time, 2 May 2016

 

Assignments

44.  Individual items

Chengcheng, Chiara: Your backlog assignments for week 5 (written answers to Assignments 38 through 43, printed in my pigeonhole) are due this Friday, 8 Mar 19, at 1:00pm.

Left over from last week:

– Whitfield & Stein, assignments 39 through 43

In today's session, we will discuss these assignments first.


45.  Read "Writing on language" and bring your reading notes.

We will discuss your questions and remarks in class.

46.  Read Murphy Paul (2016) and bring your reading notes to class.

We will discuss your questions and remarks. (and observations ;-)

47.  We are returning to the subject of your term papers.

In your notes, check my comments on your assignment #33, and be prepared to report on your progress so far.

Assignments heads-up

On Monday, 25 March (Block 4, Session 1: after the semester break), a first draft of your term paper will be expected.

This draft will be assessed as Hand-in Assignment #2.

For general hints on linguistic writing, please consult Writing on language.

Two weeks later, on Monday, 8 April (Block 4, Session 3), you will be expected to deliver a (very short!) oral report on the subject of your term paper.

This report will be assessed as your Oral presentation.

As announced, in order to help you plan ahead, you can prepare draft versions of your term paper at any time:

  • I will return your work with my comments
  • This list of proofreaders' marks may assist you in reading my comments
  • In case you wish to discuss my comments, please make an appointment

Please allow two days between handing in any draft and your appointment.

 

...and the encore

 

48.  What is this?

 


Block 4

Week 1 (25 Mar 19)


Language and script (2): Chinese writing and writing Chinese

Welcome back!

At the outset of Block 4, we will continue to explore the similarities and differences between language and script – especially as inspired by the progress made in your own coursework.

Also, as announced: it's assignment hand-in time again! Make sure to have your work ready and presentable, and to report any problems timely.

Texts

Wiedenhof (2015)

Wiedenhof (2005)


Assignments

Hand-in Assignment #2

Write a short first draft of your term paper. Hand it in, printed on paper, at the beginning of class on 25 March, or in my pigeonhole beforehand.

Please note the format format requirements.

  • Maximum length: 2 sheets A4
  • Please do not not write text about your paper, but text for your paper

Please keep the scope of this version restricted – you can always elaborate later.

Make sure you hand in at least two more draft versions during term.

The more versions you hand in, the more feedback you will get. For general hints on linguistic writing, see Writing on language.

My pigeonhole (at the Arsenaal building, first floor) is available for your (printed!) work at any time during term.

As mentioned in class: please feel free to discuss your plans and ideas, but do not wait until the last moment to make an appointment.

Bottomline: the preparations in Block 3 and the assignments of Block 4 are designed to turn the option of handing in your term paper by the last session in May (i.e. long before the official June deadline) into a realistic possibility.

– "Purpose and effect":

49.  Read the text and bring your notes.

We will discuss your questions and remarks in class.

50.  Section 2.1 mentions a modern (20th-century) instance of linguistic change in spoken Mandarin that is frequently overlooked.

In one or two sentences, write down how this situation came about.

– "The transcription of Mandarin":

51.  Read the text and bring your notes.

We will discuss your questions and remarks in class.

52.  In your own words, describe the difference between Character Pinyin and Linguistic Pinyin.

53.  The transcription dilemma mentioned at the bottom of p. 419 is also addressed in the "Purpose and effect" text, in Section 2.2.

Please summarize this dilemma in your own words, clearly distinguishing phonetic, phonological and transcription issues.

By way of orientation, consider ways of filling out the blanks in the following table.

Language

 

 

 

 

Semantics

 

'Good shot!'

Phonetics

 

 

Phonology

 

 

Morphology

 

 

Syntax

 

 

...

...

Script

 

 

 

 

 

Chinese characters

 

好球!

Pinyin

Character Pinyin (CP)

 

Linguistic Pinyin (LP)

 

Wade-Giles

 

 

Yale

 

 

Bopomofo

 

 

...

...

...

...

...

...

 

FYI

Marmite update

As we saw, early European exploration in China was supported by developments in food technology.

A century later, the fate of Marmite serves to illustrate the dilemmas of the Brexit puzzle:

"Going Dutch" (in Dutch)


Week 2 (1 Apr 19)


Brushes with power: Script and society

This week, we are finding out some facts from the fifties and sixties which helped shape the Chinese script's current destiny.

Texts

Handel (2013)

Kraus (1991)

Wiedenhof (2015)

"Features of the Chinese script"

In: Jeroen Wiedenhof, A grammar of Mandarin.

Amsterdam: John Benjamins, 2015,

§ 12.3, pp. 365-384.

Availability at Leiden:

  • from the Asian Library, on the linguistics handbooks shelves;
  • as an e-book, through the University Library catalogue


Assignments

54.  Read all three texts and bring your notes.

We will discuss your questions and remarks in class.

– "Can a logographic script be simpli­fied?"

55.  We will discuss this article first, on a page-by-page basis, and on the basis of your remarks.

Cheyann, in view of your term paper preparations, you have a special responsibility here!

 

– "The failed assault on Chinese characters"

56.  On p. 75 of Kraus' text, he notes the Korean use of "a more clearly phonetic" script instead of characters.

a.  What is the name of this script? How and when did it come into being?

b.  How "clearly phonetic" is it?

c.  If the Chinese script is not "clearly phonetic", then how could it best be characterized?

[Item d added Thu 28 Mar 19 – Thank you, Cheyann!]

d.  The phonetic nature of the native Korean script have engendered some enthousiasm about its qualities among linguists and educators.*)

For an example, see "In praise of: The world's best writing system, which states:

"it turns out that different writing systems are not all equally well equipped to capture the full range of a language’s grammar".

Give a concrete example of one grammatical feature, in a language of your choice, plus a writing system unequipped to capture that feature.

_____  

*) Apart from Korea's script, its language has likewise received distinguished praise, albeit by non-linguists, e.g. "Korean is, as a matter of fact, a very good language" in Kim Il Sung, "Problems related to the development of the Korean language", Works, Volume 18: January - December 1964, Pyongyang, Foreign Languages Publishing House, 1984, p. 17. (in BB "Course Documents")

 

57.  Kraus' chapter repeatedly mentions John DeFrancis' work.

a.  If you are not familiar with John DeFrancis' name:

do look up some details about his life and work.

b.  On p. 78, Kraus states that "DeFrancis points out that..." without quoting a source.

Can you trace this citation?

c.  Kraus paraphrases DeFrancis' statement that in the 1950s, "no one in China was willing to appear to challenge Stalin on this point".

On what point, exactly?

58.  P. 81 shows a woodcut from a 1958 issue of the journal 中国妇女 Zhōngguó Fùnǚ "Women of China".

a.  Can you identify the characters in this illustration?

b.  Can you translate them? (A friendly reminder: prepare all your answers in writing)

59.  On p. 82, Kraus mentions a childhood memory from Chinese opera singer 新凤霞 Xīn Fèngxiá (1927-1998) featuring a "discarded cap of a fountain pen".

a.  When and where were fountain pens invented? What writing tool(s) where they meant to replace or supplement?

b.  When were they first used in China? What writing tool(s) did they replace, or supplement?

 

– "Features of the Chinese script"

60.  The first paragraph of p. 365 describes what characters "consist of".

What consequences can this phrase "consist of" have in terms of linguistic methodology?

61.  For each of the stroke-order principles in Table 12.5, try to find at least one exception.

62.  For native speakers of Mandarin:

in Table 12.10, compare these letter names with your own pronunciation, and note down any differences.

63.  In Table 12.11, can you think of punctuation marks which are missing?

64.  At the bottom of page 371, what do the slashes transcribe in "the sound /s/"?

Can you write these three examples – cent, sent and scent – using the same transcription?

65.  At the bottom of p. 372, please comment on the English translation "A book from the sky".

66.  The small text of p. 375, mentions a "danger of circularity".

Please formulate this danger in two or three sentences of your own.

67.  Some historical aspects of the character 年 are mentioned on p. 377.

What linguistic terminology is available to describe the relationship between 'millet', 'harvest' and 'year' discussed here?

68.  Section 12.3.3 discusses the 六書 liù shū 'Six Categories of the Script'.

In his 2009 "Ludic writing" article, Wolfgang Behr proposes a highly original model for the analysis of the relationship written characters and linguistic signs.

This model, in his words (2009: 291)

"allows us to identify certain character structures beyond the coverage by the traditional “six scripts” (liùshū 六書) theory of the Hàn dynasty, [...] whose inadequacies have long been noted and discussed."

Can you give concrete examples (quoting individual characters) of such "inadequacies"?

69.  Table 12.14 illustrates the large propertion of infrequent characters.

Can you identify one or more social factors which have contributed to the survival of infrequent characters?

 

FYI

NPCW | New Perspectives on Chinese Writing

We aim to bring together:

  • Expert accounts of new data
  • Original results in script research
  • Hands-on presentations of materials from special library collections
Time: Monday, 20 May 2019, 10:30am to 5:00pm
Venue: University Library, Vossius Room
Registration: Entrance is free but seats are limited; details at the Leiden University Library site.

Week 3 (8 Apr 19)


Term-paper presentations

Today's session will consist of three parts:

  • Oral presentations:

    Eight five-minute overviews, each introducing ongoing work on one term paper.

  • Discussion of these presentations:

    Feedback on research quesions, methodology, presentation styles and further prospects.

  • Features of the Chinese script:

    Your comments, and the remaining assignments from last week.

Oral presentation

On 8 April, as announced, a very short oral presentation will be expected of you about the subject of your term paper.

Points of consideration:

  • Your presentation will be in English
  • Maximum duration is five minutes – please time yourself in preparation!
  • Your target audience intelligent and interested, but not necessarily trained in linguistics or in Chinese. Fellow students from other departments may be invited to listen in.
  • A short handout for the audience will come in handy, because it will save you time writing on the blackboard: please prepare 9 copies
  • Powerpoints are allowed, but only after prior consulation (over email) – also note that setting up your system will cut into your five minutes!

Assignments

– "Features of the Chinese script"

Left over form last week's session: assignments 60 to 69. (now with correct numbering ;-)


Week 4 (15 Apr 19)


Language and script (3): Documenting Chinese

In week 2, we looked at 20th-century reforms and standardization, both in the spoken and in the written domain.

Throughout history, these two domains, language and script, have often been treated as indistinguishable: not just in the public eye, but also in learned treatments and official policies. Even today, a principled distinction between these two domains often remains the prerogative of linguistics.

This week provides some background to the interplay between present-day issues of script and language in China, with roots and causes dating back to late imperial times.

Text

Coblin (2000)

W. South Coblin, "A brief history of Mandarin"

    In: Journal of the American Oriental Society

    Volume 120, no. 4, 2000, pp. 537-552.

Available online at the Leiden University Library.

 

Background

Pulleyblank (1984)

  • "The history of 'standard Chinese' "

  • "The phonology of Pekingese"

In: Edwin Pulleyblank, Middle Chinese

Vancouver: Universiy of British Columbia Press, 1984.

  • "The history of 'standard Chinese'" = pp. 1-4
  • "The evidence for Old Chinese" = Chapter 2, pp. 41-59

Available from the Asian Library, on the linguistics handbooks shelves.

 

Assignments

Left over from week 2:

– "Features of the Chinese script"

assignments 60 to 69.

 

70.  Check your progress with the term paper, and bring any questions to class.

 

– "A brief history of Mandarin"

As always, prepare your answers to all questions & assignments in writing.

Page numbers followed by a slash and the letter L or R (e.g. "p. 537/L") indicate the left or right column on the page.

71.  Read the text and bring your notes.

We will discuss your questions and remarks in class.

72.  Be sure to identify and look up linguistic terms as well as historical names & events you are unfamiliar with

– and/or to brush up your knowledge on these items.

73.  Provide your own English translations for each of the book titles mentioned on p. 537/R.

In the remainder of the article, keep checking that you understand the titles of all works discussed.

74.  As mentioned in Four tones (Middle Chinese), the 入 tone (p. 538/L) is labeled as "entering or checked" in English.

a.  Please check the etymology of the Chinese term.

b.  Can you guess how the English labels originated?

75.  Please summarize the conclusion at the bottom of p. 538/R in your own words.

76.  On p. 540/L, the Arte de la lengua mandarina and Vocabulario de la lengua mandarina by Francisco Varo are mentioned.

Check if modern editions of both these works are available – and if so, who are the editor(s).

77.  On p. 542/R, it is explained that "the zhèngyīn system of ca. 1450 was based not on the pronunciation of a single dialect or area but was instead a composite entity".

a.  What could be the reason that a purported linguistic standard is in fact composite in nature?

b.  Cite both advantages and drawbacks of a standard of this nature for its speakers;

and for linguists of later generations.

c.  Can you cite other (historical and/or modern) examples of composite linguistic standards in China?

78.  As noted on p. 543/L, Jiǎng Shàoyú 蔣紹愚 has pointed out that for historical stages of Chinese, "spoken material has [...] been accessible only indirectly through the medium of the literary sources".

a.  Please paraphrase this statement in your own words, and/or give an example.

b.  Compare this state of affairs with the status of spoken materials in the description of the modern standard language as it arose in the twentieth century.

What sources for spoken Mandarin were linguists using in, say, the 1950s?

79.  In the short abstract of this article (p. 537), it is explained that the text exposes a "flawed" view about the provenance of standard Mandarin.

a.  Is there a difference in meaning between the terms

standard Mandarin as used here ("in its oldest sense", p. 537/L);

standard Chinese as used by Pulleyblank (1984: 1); and

Modern Chinese?

If so: please indicate the difference(s).

And if not: check if these terms differ in other way (e.g. style, user base, varieties of English)?

In linguistics as in any other branch of scientific research, flawed views are problematic only inasfar they cannot be falsified; otherwise, their very falsification helps science progress.

b.  Give examples of flawed views in the field of language reconstruction (not necessarily Chinese) which have since been falsified.

c.  Give examples of views in linguistics which cannot be falsified.

FYI

Wénlín

Here is some information on the Wénlín software suite which was mentioned in a class presentation:

"Wenlin Software for Learning Chinese integrates a variety of tools for instant-access to more than 300,000 Chinese-English entries, 73,000 Chinese character entries, 62,000 English-Chinese entries, and 11,000 Seal Script entries.

Wenlin’s versatile and easy-to-use interface tackles the most frustrating obstacles for students, scholars, and speakers of Chinese.

Wenlin’s integrated solution runs on a variety of computer platforms (including Mac and Windows), and includes expandable Chinese dictionaries, a full-featured Unicode text editor, a flashcard system, pronunciation recordings, handwriting recognition, and much more."

For more information see the Wenlin Institute products page.

Formula One

The Formula 1 Heineken Chinese Grand Prix 2019 races are currently being organized in Shanghai, China.

The Shanghai International Circuit (which has various Chinese names, e.g. 上海国际赛车场 Shànghǎi Guójì Sàichēchǎng) was purpose-built for Formula One racing events.

This race circuit's tracks were designed to produce a bird's-eye view of a gigantic character shàng 'up' (as in 上海 Shànghǎi).

Can you think of other examples (in China or elsewhere) of architectural or artificial-landscape outlines which are borrowed from or inspired by script forms?

生僻字 Shēngpì zì


Week 5 (22 Apr 19)

 

No class today

Easter Monday

 

 

Week 6 (29 Apr 19)


From bones to bytes: The digital revolution

As we saw, the earliest extant specimens of Chinese writing are preserved in hard materials: bones, shells and bronze. Yet the characteristic looks of the character script were determined by soft and flexible materials: brush, paper and silk.

After the 10th century, new printing techniques created a boost in the transmission of science, literature and the arts. Movable type became cost-effective much later, after the steam engine allowed mechanization in the late 19th century.

In terms of "material" culture, the digital revolution is perhaps the most radical development in the history of the Chinese script, and of scripts generally. In terms of documentation and analysis, we will examine an overview and consider a number of special angles.

Texts

Wiedenhof (2015)

"The digital revolution"

In: Jeroen Wiedenhof, A grammar of Mandarin.

Amsterdam: John Benjamins, 2015,

§ 12.5.2, pp. 402-406.

Availability at Leiden:

  • from the Asian Library, on the linguistics handbooks shelves;
  • as an e-book, through the University Library catalogue

Apple (2017)

[Apple] Handwriting Recognition Team, "Real-time recognition of handwritten Chinese characters spanning a large inventory of 30,000 Characters"

Machine learning journal,

Volume 1, Issue 5, September 2017

 

 

Background

Russell (2016)

"Signing off: Finnish schools phase out handwriting classes"

The guardian, 31 July 2015.

Hilburger (2016)

Christina Hilburger, "Character amnesia: An overview"

In: Victor H. Mair, ed., Sinitic language and script in East Asia: Past and present

Sino-Platonic papers, Number 264, December 2016, pp. 51-70.

 

Reading notes

–"The digital revolution"

80.  The reference quoted here is Halpern and Kerman's "Pitfalls & Complexities" article, available from the CJK Dictionary Institute's website.

–"Real-time recognition"

81.  In the introduction, if you wonder what "convolutional neural networks (CNNs)" are: don't worry, they will be illustrated in the next section.

Or if you can't wait: here's a clever introduction. And note the human angle: CNNs "take a biological inspiration from the visual cortex".

 

Assignments

Assignment heads-up

On Monday, 6 May (Block 4, Session 7), a near-final draft of your term paper will be expected.

This draft will be assessed as Hand-in Assignment #3.

 

82.  Read both texts and bring your notes.

We will discuss your questions and remarks in class.

 

– "The digital revolution"

83.  As mentioned on p. 402, there are "persistent issues" in the conversion of characters between digital standards (compare the Reading Notes)

The notion of conversion, e.g. from 貝 to 贝, or vice versa, involves more than just a distinction. Conversion also denotes a degree of identity between the object and the result of the conversion. In this example, there is also a certain sameness between 貝 and 贝.

This leads us back to the linguistic leitmotiv of our course on scripts, and a consideration which will be relevant to many (if not all) of your term papers.

Whether we are linguists or not, the analyis of scripts requires a statement on the position allotted to language – "language" in the technically strict sense of the spoken (not the written) medium.

For this example:

a.  Can we establish the degree of identity between 貝 and 贝 without reference to language? And between between 後 and 后?

b.  How can we do this?

84.  The character 与 "with a horizontal stroke crossing the downward hook, has increased in popularity within the Chinese script" (p. 403).

When you look at the previous sentence (i.e. here, on this webpage) is the horizontal stroke crossing the downward hook, yes or no?

85.  The software illustrated in Figure 12.24 (p. 406) was referenced above.

The following is an experiment, not a contest.

a.  Note down (strictly individually, and without consulting any dictionary) how many characters you know actively among the ten characters displayed in Figure 12.24.

Here, "actively" means that:

  • you can pronounce the character's reading in one Sinitic language of your choice
  • and you know a corresponding meaning, i.e. a meaning in that same language

We will compare the results statistically in class, comparing numbers between 0 and 10.

b.  Write down at least three factors which may influence the result of this comparison.

 

– "Real-time recognition"

86.  To which scientific domain(s) does this text belong?

87.  Imagine you are an aspiring sino-techie applying for a job in a software company.

Describe at least one specialist asset that you bring to the firm thanks to your training in the Humanities.

88.  The Introduction mentions the phrase "underlying character inventory".

The term underlying suggests a conversion, but this type of conversion differs from the one above.

In the context of the Apple article, what are the object and the result of the conversion?

89.  In the section on "System configuration", we have a character of 48x48 pixels.

a.  In terms of resolution, is this currently a realistic average? (–on screens? –in print? –in other domains?)

b.  For fluent reading, what is the minimally required (square) resolution for Chinese characters?

90.  In the same section, the number 30,000 is mentioned for

"one node per class, e.g., 3,755 for the Hànzì level-1 subset of GB2312-80, and close to 30,000 when scaled up to the full inventory"

The text that follows will mention "30,000 characters".

In your own words, what is the difference between 30,000 nodes per class and 30,000 characters?

91.  The same number re-emerges in the title of the next section, "Scaling up to 30K characters".

a.  What type of interests drove this feat of engineering?

b.  How does the number of 30,000 compare to the numbers of characters usually addressed in educational, political and/or social domains?

92.  The same section distinguishes a "character inventory" from "[r]endered fonts".

In your own words, what is the difference?

93.  Compare the headings of Figures 2, 3 and 4 with the first sentence below Figure 4.

What is the difference between "cursive" and "unconstrained" variants (i.e. "variations")?

94.  Figures 7 presents "Similar shapes of U+738 (王) and U+4E94 (五)".

a.  For the characters 王 and 五, can the corresponding handwritten forms be completely identical, or will these two always be distinguished?

b.  If you do not know the answer to a., describe two different methods to solve this question (you do not need to actually perform these steps).

95.  In the "Discussion" section, the text returns to a nagging driving force in Chinese lexicography: personal names.

For persons whose Chinese names are written with characters which have no digital code, what are the current options for digital registration?

FYI

The British Library has opened an exhibition about writing systems entitled "Writing: Making Your Mark".

The exhibition was reviewed by Camaron Laux for the "BBC Culture" website (26 April 2019).

Can you spot a myth or two about Chinese characters being kept alive by this review?


Week 7 (6 May 19)


The future of Chinese writing

Longevity is perhaps the most striking feature of Chinese writing.

As we have seen, longevity requires a great deal of adaptability. Throughout the history of writing in China, shifts in form and function have been affected by – and have feed back into – material, social, cultural, political, economic and educational circumstances.

Extraordinary longevity also inevitably raises the question what the future will bring.

Overview

A number of milestones in the development of Chinese writing have passed in review over the last few weeks, roughly in chronological order.

For the final laps of our course, here is what is left in store:

Today (session 7)

  • Our gaze into the crystal ball starts where we left off last time, with the background readings of that session serving as our primary focus for today.

  • Your last hand-in assignment (#3) is also due. In the context of your term paper, this will also be the last opportunity to share remaining issues for discussion in class.

Next week (session 8)

  • Our insights in material culture will be strengthened through a hands-on excursion in the ethnographical depot of Leiden's Museum Volkenkunde.
  • That final session also features an (anonymous) student evaluation of this class. Your feedback help us improve future runs of this course.

 

Texts

Hilburger (2016)

Christina Hilburger, "Character amnesia: An overview"

In: Victor H. Mair, ed., Sinitic language and script in East Asia: Past and present

Sino-Platonic papers, Number 264,

December 2016, pp. 51-70.

Russell (2016)

"Signing off: Finnish schools phase out handwriting classes"

The guardian, 31 July 2015.

 

Background

Almog (2018)

Reassessing the evidence of Chinese "Character amnesia"

SOAS University of London, 2018

Accessible online through the University Library catalogue

 

Assignments

Hand-in Assignment #3

Write a near-final draft of your term paper.

Hand it in, either in PDF or printed on paper, on or before Monday 6 May.

Please note the format format requirements.

96.  Note down any remaining issues related to the progress in your term paper.

If you want, you can share your experiences as well as your doubts for discussion in class.

97.  Read both texts and bring your notes.

We will discuss your questions and remarks in class.

 

FYI

Beyond the context of this course (in case your sinographic appetite has not yet been satisfied ;-) you are most welcome to join the symposium on Chinese writing which will be held here at Leiden on the Monday following our last session of this term.

NPCW | New Perspectives on Chinese Writing

We aim to bring together:

  • Expert accounts of new data
  • Original results in script research
  • Hands-on presentations of materials from special library collections

Time: Monday, 20 May 2019, 10:30am to 5:00pm
Venue: University Library, Vossius Room
Registration: Entrance is free but seats are limited.


Week 8 (13 May 19)

Outro / Evaluation and excursion

Today's session consists of three parts:

 

(1) Optional hand-in of your term paper:

    As announced, you may hand in your paper and conclude your course today.

    Alternatively, you can take some more time and hand in your paper by the official deadline (see details).

 

(2) Excursion:

    We start at the usual time, but out venue is in the Volkenkunde museum

    We will meet each other at the entrance of the Boerhaave building

    This buiding is on your left, immediately after you enter the iron gates. | Click map to enlarge

    Steenstraat 1

    2312 BS Leiden

 

(3) Course evaluation:

    As part of the last session of the course, Leiden University organizes a formal student evaluation. The evaluation process takes 5 to 10 minutes. It is anonymous and confidential (see details).

    Apart from this formal exercise, any comments and suggestions that you wish to share about the format and contents of this course are most welcome.

Suggested background reading

Writing & scripts in general

Chinese writing & writing Chinese

Chinese character reference toolbox

Databases

Traditional texts online

Linguistic toolbox

 Terminology

 Languages of the world

 Proofreading symbols

 e-ANS

 Linguistic transcription

 Writing on language

 IPA home

 IPA sounds & videos

 

Updated 10 May 2019